R.E.M. Murmur (Vinyl, IRS Records, 1983) **** R.E.M. Reckoning (Vinyl and CD, IRS Records, 1984) *****
R.E.M. Fables of the Reconstruction (Vinyl, Epic Records, 1985) *****
R.E.M. Life's Rich Pageant (Vinyl, IRS Records, 1986) ****
R.E.M. Green (Vinyl and CD, Warner Brothers Records, 1988) ***
R.E.M. Out of Time (CD, Warner Brothers Records, 1991) ****
R.E.M. Automatic For the People (Vinyl, Warner Brothers Records, 1992) ****
R.E.M. Reveal (Vinyl and CD, Warner Brothers Records, 2001) ****
Genre: Alt rock
Places I remember: Marbecks Records, music store in New Plymouth in the eighties (Reckoning and Fables on vinyl, HMV for deluxe CD edition of Reckoning), JB Hi Fi (Reveal)
Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Harborcoat (Reckoning)
Gear costume: Driver 8 (Fables of the Reconstruction); Losing My Religion , Shiny Happy People (Out of Time), Imitation of Life (Reveal)
They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1; Part 2; Part 3; Part 4; Part 5; Part 6
Active compensatory factors: Harborcoat and the Reckoning album was my entry drug into the world of Rapid Eye Movement (R.E.M.). We (Jacky, me and new baby Keegan) were living in the pink house in List Street, New Plymouth, and the album was on high rotate. So much so that I instantly associate these songs to that time and place - spring, 1984.
It still sounds fresh as newly mowed grass to these ears. Every song is a work of genius. Harborcoat, Seven Chinese Brothers, Rockville, Persuasion, Second Guessing...every song hits the heights.
I backtracked to Murmur and was a little disappointed at the time. It's grown on me since, but it sounds muddy and doesn't have the pop smarts of Reckoning. Radio Free Europe is the clear standout but Michael Stipe's vocals are pretty buried, not that he sings the words clearly enough to be understood anyway. He sings in the same way on Reckoning but the production is a lot crisper.
From then on I was onboard and collecting each album as they were released. Fables of the Reconstruction was next in 1985. It's a darker, moodier album than the bright Reckoning, with Stipe still slurring his vocals so that only vague phrases can be heard. I love this!
The album a year procession continued with Life's Rich Pageant in 1986. It's a tougher sounding album, which points the way forward to a more mainstream rock sound. Stipe's lyrics are starting to emerge from the murk with a much cleaner production than on Fables of the Reconstruction, with Bill Berry's drums pushed more to the foreground.
I have previously owned a copy of Document (their next album after Life's Rich Pageant) but before going to live in the UK in 2004, I flicked it off. So, the next R.E.M. album in my collection is Green. The one with the orange cover (ho ho).
I'm not that fond of Green. It has some great moments (Stand, Orange Crush for instance), but a lot of it feels like a work in progress. Still, their major label debut is considered a success overall.
Out of Time followed Green. This is the one with mega hit Losing My Religion on it. It's an upbeat record of pop and folk songs with lots of lush new sounds, which also still sounds like classic R.E.M. As such it's an album that I find very rewarding. I love that mandolin sound! Shiny Happy People sort of sums up things well. A great sunny pop song.
Automatic for the People was their eighth studio album. By this point the band was into veteran status on a major label. The album turned into a massive success, with six singles taken from it.
AllMusic summed up the album well: Turning away from the sweet pop of Out of Time, R.E.M. created a haunting, melancholy masterpiece with Automatic for the People. At its core, the album is a collection of folk songs about aging, death, and loss, but the music has a grand, epic sweep provided by layers of lush strings, interweaving acoustic instruments, and shimmering keyboards.
It's that sweet pop I prefer though, so, although everyone raves about the album, I do prefer the sweet pop of Out of Time and Reveal.
Before Reveal, I bought the next few R.E.M. albums but they went along with Document. For me, the band's albums after Automative for the People became a case of diminishing returns. Monster's guitar riffarama seemed the opposite of what they were about. The experimental Up was not for me.
My final R.E.M. album, Reveal, was bought because of a great couple of iconic videos: All the Way to Reno and Imitation of Life. They were very R.E.M. - clever, and melodic. The band had returned to their core sound and playfulness while reining in the willfully experimental sounds of Up.
Where do they all belong? There aren't any R.E.M. albums on my list to buy. I'll continue to play Reckoning, Reveal, Pageant, Fables, and Out of Time in the future without needing to buy the albums I don't have.