The Pineapple Thief All the Wars (CD, Kscope Records, 2012) **** The Pineapple Thief Magnolia (CD, Kscope Records, 2012) *****
The Pineapple Thief Your Wilderness (CD, Kscope Records, 2016) ***
The Pineapple Thief Where We Stood (CD/DVD, Kscope Records, 2017) ****
The Pineapple Thief Dissolution (CD, Kscope Records, 2018) ****
The Pineapple Thief Versions of the Truth (CD, Kscope Records, 2020) ****
The Pineapple Thief Give it Back (Vinyl, Kscope Records, 2022) ****
The Pineapple Thief It Leads to This (Vinyl, Kscope Records, 2024) *****
Genre: Prog rock, Prog metal
They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1; Part 2; Part 3; Part 4; Part 5; Part 6; Part 7
Active compensatory factors: Bruce and the band started the new millennium in great shape following their excellent album from 2010 (Someone Here Is Missing).
All the Wars is a really confident album which develops the thrust of Someone Here is Missing. As the reviewer in Record Collector wrote - Bruce Soord's songs "aren’t mere entertainments; they’re demanding pieces, both muscular and intricate, concerned with conflicts and dislocation, charting personal battles drawn out on large canvases".
All the Wars delivers on all fronts with some great sounding prog rock songs. The sonic landscape is as carefully considered as the lyrics.
Magnolia is even better. With some judicious editing of the songs - all are reasonably brief (none are over 6 minutes), it's a more streamlined rock sound. Ironically, that allows each song to luxuriate via the more economical songcraft and some excellent hooks. Magnolia is in many ways my go-to album by The Pineapple Thief. It's lean and mean and catchy as hell.
Your Wilderness is their eleventh studio album. The band was essentially now down to a trio (Bruce, Jon Sykes on bass and Steve Kitch on keyboards) with special guests fleshing out the instrumentation. These included Gavin Harrison (Porcupine Tree, King Crimson), John Helliwell (Supertramp), and Geoffrey Richardson (Caravan).
The resulting sound is a return to the band's sound from eight years before. That means it's far less rocky and much more introspective. I do like this side of the band, but I also like the Magnolia version and, truth be told, I actually prefer it as well.
Where We Stood is a live package - CD and DVD. The band are caught live in London on their final show of their 2017 tour. They deliver a terrific set in an intimate setting.
Their next studio album was Dissolution, again with Gavin Harrison onboard (he was also on Where We Stood).
As the black and white cover image and the title suggests this one is looking at a dissolving world. Specifically, the subject matter concerns the dark side of social media and hyper-technology; exploring the ways in which they contribute to isolation, alienation, and the disintegration of relationships.
Although the subject matter is pretty bleak, the music isn't. Instead it is, as AllMusic summarised, 'poetic, erudite, emotionally powerful, and chock-full of musical imagination'.
Their 13th album, Versions of the Truth, maintained the stable lineup of Soord, Harrison, Kitch and Sykes and it also maintained the high quality. The theme this time is how we now live in a post truth world thanks to American politicians and leaders.
Give it Back continued the forward momentum by revisiting the past. Specifically, it means 12 new versions of songs taken from the albums 137 to All The Wars.
The re-recorded versions feature new drum parts by Gavin Harrison (who wasn't in the band when those three albums were released initially). Bruce Soord also took the opportunity to tutu with song arrangements.
It sounds superb, as you'd expect, and is nice to have (I love the cover image), but it's still a kind of holding operation during the covid lockdowns.
The final album on my list, It Leads to This, is also the band's 15th and latest - from 2024.
Bruce Soord's world view can be quite bleak and who can blame him in the 2020s. I sometimes feel that modern life is rubbish and Bruce provides the sounds to go with that sentiment. It Leads to This is superb - clear eyed (like the cover) and thoughtful. This one is up there with their best, maybe even THE best? Time will tell.
Where do they all belong? That's it for The Pineapple Thief for now. Their albums certainly deserve repeat listens as there are always new discoveries to be made.