Friday, January 31, 2025

Entertainment is my business (Country Joe McDonald) (LP 3181 - 3182)

Country Joe McDonald   Incredible! Live! Country Joe! (Vinyl, Vanguard Records, 1972) ***  

Country Joe McDonald   Goodbye Blues (Vinyl, Fantasy Records, 1977) ***  

Genre: Folk rock 

Places I remember: RCA Music club; Real Groovy Records

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Kiss My Ass (Incredible! Live!)

Gear costume: Walk In Santiago

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: Country Joe and Arlo Guthrie are kindred spirits. 

They are both loveable rogues who play lovely guitar (Walk In Santiago), are rebels with a cause, happy to play the jester/fool role, poke fun at politicians (Tricky Dicky), play endearing folk rock ditties about war (Kiss My Ass), and are funny as all get out. The sixties were perfect for them.

They also operate well live with a small audience so they can spark off people, tell their shaggy dog stories (Country Joe's one is You Know What I Mean- a meeting between himself and the police) and have a good time.

Incredible! Live! Country Joe!  is recorded live (der) at The Bitter End in New York City and succeeds for the most part. Of course, the political stuff does date the proceedings somewhat. Still and all, he is an excellent entertainer!

Goodbye Blues subs out the political material and subs in the activist material. So - worthy topics like slaughtering seals for fur, killing whales, and destroying the wildness get an airing. He is effective, too, in creating catchy tunes to house these topical protests. 

Interestingly, this album isn't on Spotify (although Incredible! Live! is) and none of the songs on it make his compilation on Spotify. I do have two CD compilations - Classics does have a couple - Blood On The Ice, and Copiapo.

Where do they all belong? A seminal figure in folk rock. Don't forget him!

Rock and roll springtime take 6 - Paul is live (Paul McCartney) (LP 3172 - 3180)

Wings  Wings Over America (Vinyl, MPL Comms, 1976) ****  

Various  Concerts For The People of Kampuchea (Vinyl, Atlantic Records, 1980) ***

Paul McCartney  Tripping The Live Fantastic - Highlights (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1990) *****  

Paul McCartney  Unplugged (The Official Bootleg) (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1991) ***** 

Paul McCartney  Paul Is Live (CD, Parlophone Records, 1993) *** 

Paul McCartney  Back In The U.S. - Live 2002 (CD, Capitol Records, 2002) *** 

Paul McCartney  Good Evening New York City (2CD/DVD, Hear Music, 2009) ***   

Paul McCartney  Amoeba Gig (CD, Capitol Records, 2019) ***** 

Paul McCartney  Paul McCartney Live (CD, Bootleg) **  

GenrePop 

Places I remember: Real Groovy Records, The Warehouse, JB Hi Fi, HMV, Amoeba Records

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Hi Hi Hi (Wings Over America)

Gear costume: I've Just Seen A Face (Unplugged)

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: Live: the man is phenomenal! I saw his live show in 2016 in Auckland and there was no trading on legacy, no phoning in a performance. He rocked Mt Smart for three hours and I was exhausted just watching!

He's been doing live shows since the sixties and he's still going. Remarkable!

His live albums outside of The Beatles started with the massive three album set - Wings Over America. It went to number one! A triple live album!! The first to ever do that.

It recreates a Wings live show and he wins the crowd over with a succession of hits. Wings is a band, so others get their turn in the limelight. Plenty to enthuse about - the acoustic set, five Beatles' numbers heard again in America, muscled up versions of Wings At The Speed Of Sound tunes, and Denny's vocals provide some variety.  Highlights: Beware My Love; a revved up Hi Hi Hi; Soily to end things on a high. 

Sidebar: Wings Over America is the album, but it's also linked to the DVD Rockshow (remastered version 2013). A great addition to the viewing library! I warmly recommend it.

The Paul McCartney and Wings/ Rockestra section of the show takes up side 4 of the Concerts For The People of Kampuchea album so the album deserves a place here. 

Paul & Wings deliver a Beatle song and two from his solo albums before the big Rockestra does its thing on three more. It's okay but the Rockestra songs sound too dense and cluttered. Yes, I appreciate that that will happen when twenty (yes, twenty) musicians vie for space. So, the BIG moment Macca dreamed of doesn't quite come off.

I have the vinyl version of Tripping The Live Fantastic - Highlights with 12 tracks culled from the big album (the CD version has 17 songs). The band is the Wix/Hamish/Robbie one and the sound is BIG and full and rocking in a much slicker way than his previous bands. Nine of the twelve are Beatles songs so it's good value for people like me. The deep cut choices are interesting too - Eleanor Rigby, Sgt Pepper, Birthday, I Saw Her Standing There are not obvious ones.

I've mentioned before how sometimes less-is-more and having a single album of highlights (and calling it that) is...erm...fantastic. Thanks Paulie!

Best of the lot so far is the Unplugged one. He and the band (again the Wix/Hamish/Robbie one) are relaxed and having a great time. The between song banter is hilarious, as well. The gig includes his first song - I Lost My Little Girl, and a great mix of Beatle songs with some rock'n'roll classics.

Paul Is Live has a great cover, but it unfortunately comes from the New World tour (behind his Off The Ground album), so along with the now customary Beatles numbers (which are great) we have live versions of songs like Looking For Changes, Peace In the Neighbourhood (yikes) and Biker Like An Icon (eek).

Back In The U.S.
is a massive double CD which documents his 2002 tour to support the Driving Rain album. He's assembled a new touring band 
Rusty Anderson and Brian Ray on guitar, Abe Laboriel Jr. on drums and Wix on keyboards. 

This is the band I saw in NZ and they remain his touring band. By now you know the set list pretty much (good to have a live C Moon, Something and Driving Rain on this one but I don't really need another live version of Coming Up thanks.

Good Evening New York City
documents his 2009 tour, so at least there was some good spacing between these last few live albums, yet the set list never varies too much. Again though, good to have live versions of Calico Skies, Sing The Changes, and Helter Skelter
This time it's a recording from one venue rather than cherry picking the best versions and that helps.

Amoeba Gig is a recording from live in the Amoeba Music store (the LA one rather than San Francisco). One of my happy places! He was touring behind Memory Almost Full - an album I love. 

So - great intimate venue, great new songs to add to the mix! Macca on top form throughout. This is a great live CD (I also have the 4 track Amoeba's Secret, but stick with the whole 21 set version - it's a winner!)

The bootleg CD, Paul McCartney Live, is from the New World Tour, and best avoided (actually it sounds like a clandestine version of songs from Paul Is Live). You can read more about it here.

Where do they all belong? Woh. That was intense. McCartney takes 6 massive posts/takes to resolve itself. That's a big deal. I need a breather! Only Ringo now to go when we get to S (he'll also need a multi-parter to get through his career).

Rock n roll springtime take 5 (LP 3167 - 3171)

Paul McCartney  Oobu Joobu - Ecology (CD, Best buy/MPL Comms, 1997) ***  

Paul McCartney  The Family Way: Concertantes, Op 1 (Variations.) - Carl Aubut/ Claudel String Quartet (CD, Phillips Records, 1996) **  

Paul McCartney  Working Classical (Cassette, EMI Records, 1999) **  

Paul McCartney  Liverpool Sound Collage (CD, EMI Records, 2000) ***  

The Fireman  Electric Arguments (CD, MPL Comms, 2008) ***  

Genre: Pop, Alt-pop, avant-garde

Places I remember: Amoeba Records, The Warehouse, Record club for the cassette, Kings Recording, Abu Dhabi, for LSC, Fopp for The Fireman.

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Sing The Changes (Electric Arguments)

Gear costume:
Two Magpies (Electric Arguments)

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: Given he's been at this music lark for decades, there are a lot of odds and sods that Macca has been associated with. Here are some (I'm not a completist). BTW: I did have a copy of Thrillington, a muzak version of Ram, but I lost it along the way in a house move; I haven't bothered to replace it. 

The Family Way was his first go at providing music for a film in 1967 (The George Martin Orchestra produced the music). 

This version of The Family Way and additional classical pieces comes from 1996. It's a new recording of The Family Way love theme as a classical suite for guitar and flute. It's a nice piece of music, but not an essential item by any stretch.   

Oobu Joobu - Ecology
is a CD put together as a promo. It
 features the fifth show of Paul’s award-winning U.S. radio series – an episode he designated an environment special, so we get Looking For Changes from a soundtrack and various other rare items. Linda McCartney's Cow doesn't work, no wonder it's unreleased, but her vegie burger recipe is fun.

His classical work doesn't appeal to me much. That said, Working Classical displays his talents as a composer. So, if Junk and other songs done with LSO and chamber music is your jam - jump aboard. He must have a touch of ADHD - his fevered brain jumps all over the shop from project to project. He never appears to sit still.

The avant-garde and wildly experimental side to his work can be found in these last two albums. The Liverpool Sound Collage gives Lennon's Life With The Lions a run for its money. 

It uses some old Beatle studio chatter along the way and creates five soundscape collages. It's not a million miles away from Revolution #9 on The Beatles, although that was really only George, John and Yoko's work. If you like that (as I do) you will be able to tolerate this, although 60 minutes is a harder prospect. It should be stressed - Liverpool Sound Collage is not a long lost Beatle album!

The Fireman is a project Paul has taken on with Youth. They'd already done a few experimental electronica albums, Electric Arguments being their third and latest to date. It's the only one with vocals.

Right from the first track (Nothing Too Much Just Out Of sight), it's notable for Macca getting loud and messy. And trying things out in a collaboration with someone (I have no idea what Youth brings to the party, I think it's a vibe thing like Eno). Favourite tracks: Two Magpies, Sing The Changes.

Where do they all belong? Next time out - a clutch of live albums rounds out the McCartney collection.

Rock and roll springtime take 4 (LP 3161 - 3166)

Paul McCartney  Driving Rain (CD, Parlophone Records, 2001) ****  

Paul McCartney  Chaos And Creation In The Backyard (CD and DVD, Parlophone Records, 2005) ****  

Paul McCartney  Memory Almost Full (CD, Hear Music, 2007) *****  

Paul McCartney  Kisses On The Bottom (CD, Hear Music, 2012) **  

Paul McCartney  New (CD, Universal Music, 2013) ***

Paul McCartney  McCartney III (CD, Capitol Records, 2021) ***

GenrePop 

Places I remember: Fopp, HMV, JB Hi Fi

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Only Mama Knows, The End Of The End (Memory Almost Full)

Gear costume: Jenny Wren (Chaos and Creation in the Backyard)

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: It's been a good idea to group these albums together in decades because the 2000's produced a rejuvenated Macca, with a different sound.

First and foremost, his vocals began to change. For the first time they are showing signs of wear and tear. Not surprising given he'd been stretching them in concert and elsewhere for most of his life. Musically, the theme of the last two decades has been an attempt to embrace a tougher sound that aims to be current.

After Run Devel Run, Driving Rain is the second pop album he made after Linda's passing in 1998, and the first that has songs for his second wife - Heather Mills (they married in 2002). He was also busy with other projects, classical and otherwise, as well during this period. Music is his stillness.

Driving Rain's a good effort for the most part. Rinse The Raindrops is my favourite on the album. He stretches out and jams for a bit on various riffs. A welcome sign!

Chaos And Creation In The Background
came out during his marriage with Heather, they would separate in 2006. It continues the late career flourish that began with Flaming Pie. There is a nice intimacy to the album and I like the more personal bent to the lyrical content. Highlight: Jenny Wren.

Memory Almost Full is a wonderful album. Even though it came out from a time Macca turned 64, it's bright and hopeful and positive right from the off (Dance Tonight kicks off things brilliantly). His marriage to Heather had ended in divorce, but this is no breakup album. There are some hints of mortality (the wonderful The End Of the End) but there are also some out and out rockers (Only Mama Knows).

Kisses On The Bottom
breaks the streak from Flaming Pie to Memory Almost Full. It's a collection of standards, mostly songs from his parents' era, with help from Diana Krall (Eric Clapton and Stevie Wonder also guest). 

I struggle with this type of album, even if it's Ringo (Sentimental Journey) or this one from Macca. It's just not my cup of (English) tea. The one song he writes for Nancy in the same style is a good one - My Valentine, but the album, as a whole, sags when the concentration is largely on his vocals.

New
is an interesting title. It must be hard for someone with a huge back catalogue to come up with something new. Seeking out younger producers and collaborators is one way to look for freshness. Generally, from the cover to the songs and the delivery, he achieves a bright and sparkling relevancy on New.

For some reason I've already written about his next studio album - Egypt Station. I think it was because I had bought it while I was living in the UK and was reviewing albums as I bought them. So that just leaves McCartney III for this post.

Even though he's been the main contributor to a few of his other solo albums (i.e. Chaos And Creation In The Backyard), this album completes the McCartney, McCartney II, McCartney III trilogy. It was eagerly anticipated in 2020 and went to the top of the album charts (I'm not sure that means too much in the digital/ Spotify era though).
 
It's similar to those other two albums in that he reacted to a potentially negative situation, in this case Covid 19 lockdown, by picking up a musical instrument (an acoustic guitar if III's songs are anything to go by). Very McCartney. And so is the album. He's been comfortable in his own skin for a long long time. Favourite track: Long Tailed Winter Bird.

You will need to adjust to his now fully weather-beaten vocals but there are plenty of rewards on this album. Don't bet against him doing another studio album!

Where do they all belong? Odds and sods, then Live albums to come.

Rock and roll springtime take 3 (LP 3158 - 3160)

Paul McCartney  Off The Ground (CD, Parlophone Records, 1993) ***  

Paul McCartney  Flaming Pie (CD, Parlophone Records, 1997) ****  

Paul McCartney  Run Devil Run (CD and Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1999) ****

GenrePop 

Places I remember: Music shop at St Lukes Mall - long gone, JB Hi Fi

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Young Boy (Flaming Pie)

Gear costume: Run Devil Run, I Got Stung (Run Devil Run) 

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: Compared to the sixties, seventies and eighties, Macca was much quieter in the nineties - just the three studio albums. Elsewhere he was involved in The Beatles Anthology project, and some side projects that I'll get to later in the odds and sods post. 

The new band was promising, with Hamish Stuart, Robbie McIntosh, and Blair Cunningham joining Wix, Linda and Paul. 

Off The Ground has some promising moments (nice production values, the title song and Hope Of Deliverance) but it flutters out in a cloud of earnestness. Macca following through on his social consciousness doesn't make for great tunes.

Flaming Pie
is much better. A proper Paul McCartney album that he somehow managed to complete even though Linda was battling cancer (she passed away in 1998). His inspiration came from The Fabs and he produces a nicely understated acoustic feel to the album. Young Boy could be a long lost Beatle song.

It's still got some padding on it - an issue in the CD years. Some of the jams with Steve Miller could have been edited out but overall this is a passable Macca album.

He went back to the oldies again for Run Devil Run and, at this stage - late nineties, this became a fun vanity project. This time he put his back into it and created some fun and quality from the reboot. He also has a few guys joining him who know what they're doing - among them Dave Gilmour, Ian Paice and Mick Green.

Nb. the album on CD also comes with a bonus interview CD.

Where do they all belong? On to the new millennium's studio albums for take 4.

Rock and roll springtime take 2 (LP 3151 - 3157)

Paul McCartney  McCartney II (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1980) 

Paul McCartney  Tug Of War (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1982) ****

Paul McCartney  Pipes Of Peace (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1983) ****

Paul McCartney  Give My Regards To Broad Street (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1984) **

Paul McCartney  Press To Play (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1986) ***

Paul McCartney  CHOBA B CCCP (Vinyl, Melodia Records, 1988) ***

Paul McCartney  Flowers In The Dirt (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1989) ****

Genre: Pop 

Places I remember: Marbecks Records; Real Groovy Records,

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Figure Of Eight (Flowers In The Dirt)

Gear costume: This One, My Brave Face, We Got Married (Flowers In The Dirt)

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: A new decade and a second homemade 'solo' album hits the shops, as in Macca takes over the whole show.

I hate 1980 and I hate McCartney II (released in May, seven months before John's murder). Sorry, not sorry. I hate 1980.

Only Waterfalls emerges from this dross with any credit, so that gets my one star. The rest is synth city, electronica driven drivel. Not my scene jellybean. Apparently, John heard Coming Up and liked it enough to help prod him back into action. So, at least it had one positive spin-off. 

A couple of years on from that drug bust in Japan, John's murder, and the dissolution of Wings, meant a retro feel to Tug Of War. George Martin was back, and so was Ringo (on Take It Away). And so were the songs!

And what songs! Ballroom Dancing, Wanderlust and Take It Away, plus the terrific tribute to John - Here Today. Four great songs. Balancing those are the less successful Stevie Wonder collaborations (What's That You're Doing is a mess and Ebony And Ivory is cringey/awkward).

It worked on Tug Of War, so it should work on Pipes Of Peace as well right? Well, yes, it does, as it happens. 

George Martin produces, Ringo and Eric Stewart reappear, and a post Thriller Michael Jackson appears on two fine songs. It's all good fun on Pipes Of Peace. 

After a rocky start to the eighties (McCartney II recalibrates him and then gets out of the way, thankfully), Macca produces two fine albums. Could he do a third?

No. He couldn't.  

Just to prove he's human, Give My Regards to Broad Street is a real clunker, both as a film and an album. But I didn't know that when I bought it in 1984 shortly before the birth of my first son. 

The signs were good - George Martin on duty for a third successful album; Ringo/Eric Stewart were back again and Dave Gilmour was a guitar guest on a good song - No More Lonely Nights. What could go wrong?

Well, this: it's an album of recreations of past solo songs and Beatles songs to serve the movie. Recreations, not reinterpretations. So, we get note for note re-recordings and some naff film dialogue spliced in to create a movie ambience. It all makes for a tough listening experience that is all pretty pointless. 

I do understand Macca's urge to reclaim a song like The Long and Winding Road after the Get Back/ Let It Be sessions experience, but this is such an anodyne version. He'd have another go with Let It Be Naked and even that couldn't replace the Phil Spectorised version. Let It Be, Macca. Let It Be.

Press To Play is another one that sounds great on paper - team up with Eric Stewart (he of the Beatles inspired 10CC) as a writing partner and watch the magic happen. Except it doesn't quite do that. It's got some nice synth-pop moments but there is not one truly memorable song on the album, and needless to say - no hits! Inconceivable!  

Footnote to this album - Split Enzer Eddie Rayner appears on keyboards. 

CHOBA B CCCP is a weird one from 1988, released in the then Soviet Union. It consists of live-in-studio recordings of covers, mainly old rock'n'roll oldies. My copy is a first pressing with 11 tracks (subsequent pressings had more tracks). 

Like John's Rock'n'Roll, it's a sincere tribute to the songs he loved growing up in the fifties. The first side is too polite and by the numbers but side 2 sparks into life with a few good moments - Crackin' Up and Just Because are notable successes. Midnight Special takes a different route to previous covers and finishes off the album in style.

Flowers In The Dirt is my favourite eighties Macca album. This is the one with the Elvis Costello collaborations on it, which add some strength of purpose to proceedings. Macca took his time to get this one right and it paid off. It's not perfect but it feels fresh and is the most consistently fun sounding album of this troubled decade.

The good material comes thick and fast, starting with the Beatle-ish My Brave Face. Other favourites - We Got Married, Put It There, Figure Of Eight, and This One.

Where do they all belong? And so on to the nineties...

Sunday, January 26, 2025

Rock and roll springtime take 1 (Paul McCartney) (LP 3140 - 3150)

Paul McCartney  McCartney (CD and Vinyl, Apple Records, 1970) ***  

Paul & Linda McCartney   Ram (CD and Vinyl, Apple Records, 1971) *****  

Wings   Wildlife (CD and Vinyl, Apple Records, 1971) ***  

Paul McCartney & Wings   Red Rose Speedway (CD and Vinyl, Apple Records, 1973) ****  

Paul McCartney & Wings   Red Rose Speedway: Reconstructed (Double Vinyl, Capitol Records, 2018) *** 

Paul McCartney & Wings   Band On The Run (CD and Vinyl, Capitol Records, 2018) *****  

Paul McCartney & Wings   One Hand Clapping (Vinyl, UMC Records, 2024) ****    

Wings   Venus And Mars (CD, MPL Comms, 1975) ***

Wings   Wings At The Speed Of Sound (Vinyl, Capitol Records, 1976) **    

Wings   London Town (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1978) **  

Wings   Back To The Egg (Vinyl, Parlophone Records, 1979) *** 

GenreApple records, pop 

Places I remember: Real Groovy Records, DJ Records, Marbecks Records

Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Little Lamb Dragonfly (Red Rose Speedway)

Gear costume: Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five (One Hand Clapping). And about 20 others - he's amazing and churns out gear songs like a tap!

They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5

Active compensatory factors
: Clearly as a Beatles obsessive I also have to have every album each member released, so I'm going to have to split the McCartney albums up into decades (plus odds/sods and live albums) because this would be a monster post otherwise. Even so they are each going to be pretty expansive posts because he's been really prolific throughout his solo career!

The seventies Macca began with an album that just gets better as the years go by. The relatively homemade McCartney showed off his precocious talent. Everything he touches isn't always solid gold, but it damn near is!

This first solo album (with only some vocal contributions from Linda) has a lot of charm, and melodies to burn. I like the half-finished doodles as well as the well-formed, completed songs like Maybe I'm Amazed and Every Night

Yes, it's lo-fi and almost amateurish in approach but it was meant to be. Anyway, the world caught up with Macca and eventually appreciated this first album for what it was - an anti-Beatle album. By that I mean he attempts to distance himself from the other three and George Martin with an album recorded away from Abbey Road (even if it was a couple of streets away).

Second album and he's hitting top gear with the more polished, well-rounded Ram. This has always been one of my favourite albums - starting with Uncle Albert/ Admiral Halsey but including the snipes at John (Too Many People, Dear Boy). 

Other favourites are the Fab tunes like The Back Seat Of My Car, Monkberry Moon Delight. Five-star classic all the way!

Wildlife
is credited to the newly created Wings. The cover is great, Tomorrow is great, but there are too many wobbly moments on it. Linda would eventually develop into a good backing vocalist, but she was never an assured solo voice. 

Dear Friend is interesting as another song directed at John but the album as a whole is dodgy.

I have a soft spot for Red Rose Speedway in its original format (the other version listed above is a 2018 release as a double album - apparently truer to Macca's original vision for the album).

First the original - it includes my favourite McCartney solo song of all time - Little Lamb Dragonfly. There are also a couple of other songs here that I love - One More Kiss and My Love (of course). I also don't have a problem with the suite of songs ending side 2.

The 2018 reconstructed double album version included Linda's Seaside Woman and I Would Only Smile and Denny Laine's Japanese Tears, various singles with their respective B-sides, early and rough mixes of several songs as well as previously unreleased studio and live recordings. It's as messy and incoherent as all that sounds. Fun to have though.

Band On The Run is a classic album. The story of how Denny, Linda, and Paul (especially) pulled this one out of the fire is well known. In adversity, genius emerged. The hits are well justified - the title track, Mrs Vandebilt, Bluebird, Let Me Roll It and especially Jet.

The Lennonism of Let Me Roll It has been mentioned before in despatches but I've also noticed how the song No Words sounds a lot like a George song - vocally and instrumentally. Eerie. 

One Hand Clapping
 was released last year, but it documents a short-lived iteration of Wings from the mid-seventies. Having just returned from Nashville and the superb Junior's Farm single, they are captured live in the Abbey Road studio in 1974. 

Geoff Britton is superb on drums and Jimmy McCulloch is in his element. They proved to be short-lived as Wings members but they added a lot of muscle to the band at the time.

They run through a staggering amount of songs on One Hand Clapping and as I listen, I'm just in awe of McCartney's seemingly unlimited ability to write catchy songs during this period. Wings were cool maan.

Venus And Mars is a good Wings album, but not a great one (unlike Band On The Run), because the material is inconsistent with real ups and downs. Downs are You Gave Me The Answer, Treat Her Gently, Crossroads theme.

But the ups are really up - Listen To What The Man Said, Letting Go, and even Magneto And Titanium Man is a lot of fun.

The return to the use of the Wings name is significant, as Macca tries to be generous with bandmates material. These emerge as good rock songs and fit the rock show remit. Sadly though, Macca is Macca! He's next level (with only John above him), and this isn't a democracy - let's not kid ourselves.

Wings At The Speed Of Sound
was a second attempt at Wings as democratic band with everyone getting at least one lead vocal. Linda is still not a solo vocalist, Denny and new drummer Joe English (both of whom who can sing) seem a bad fit for the slight material somehow.

I refused to buy this album when it was released and only picked it up years later because I had to. I really don't like it. A lot of it makes me cringe (and, shock horror, I include Paul's songs in that statement). Of course, it was a commercial monster - which just goes to show.

The better songs would toughen up in a live setting (I'll get to Wings Over America later on) but here they are mild, soft rock versions. Beware My Love is the best song on the album, but it's markedly better done live.

Although the democratic experiments were over, London Town was not a return to form. Mull of Kintyre was the non-album giant hit but would have been completely incongruous on London Town.

Yikes - how the mighty were falling. It seemed to all get too cozy - I mean recording on a luxury yacht in The Virgin Islands? Pleeze. If soft yacht rock and laid-back Paulie is your thing then this is an album for you. 

That said, there were some positive signs: I've Had Enough has potential and gives a glimpse of what he's capable of when he's not coasting on silly love songs like Warm And Beautiful. His co-write/duet with Denny on Deliver Your Children is interesting as well, although the lyrics on this and elsewhere are terrible. 

Overall though, I'm more inclined to go with Back To The Egg. At least there are some rock songs on his last album of the seventies. Evidence: Getting Closer; Spin It On; even the ensemble Rockestra Theme.

Sadly though, the rest of the album is pretty forgettable. By the end of the seventies it appears he'd run out of steam, and all of the band changes in Wings had taken their toll as well.

Where do they all belong? In summary - a great couple of years at the start of the seventies but then diminishing returns at the end of the decade. Would the eighties see a return to greatness? Tune in for the next post for the answer.