Porcupine Tree Lightbulb Sun (CD, K Scope Records, 2000) **** Porcupine Tree Recordings (CD, Snapper Records, 2001) ****
Porcupine Tree In Absentia (CD, Lava Records, 2002) *****
Porcupine Tree Deadwing (CD, Lava Records, 2005) ****
Porcupine Tree Fear of a Blank Planet (CD, Roadrunner Records, 2007) ****
Porcupine Tree Nil Recurring (CD, Transmission Records, 2007) ****
Porcupine Tree Anesthetize (CD/DVD, K Scope Records, 2013) ****
Porcupine Tree The Incident (CD, Roadrunner Records, 2009) ****
Porcupine Tree Octane Twisted (CD, K Scope Records, 2012) ****
Porcupine Tree Closure/ Continuation (CD, Music for Nations Records, 2022) ****
Genre: Prog rock
Places I remember: JB Hi Fi, HMV, Fopp
Fab, and all the other pimply hyperboles: Buying New Soul (Recordings)
Gear costume: Lazarus (Deadwing)
They loom large in his legend (The Album Collection playlists): Part 1; Part 2; Part 3; Part 4; Part 5
Active compensatory factors: The 2000's started with Lightbulb Sun and a continuation of Stupid Dream's poppier approach. I can really hear the Beatles influence on many of Lightbulb Sun's songs. There are hints of backwards guitar style innovations throughout this album. Superior pop, but it's still unmistakably Porcupine Tree.
Recordings is a collection of tracks that didn't make the Stupid Dream/ Lightbulb Sun albums and it's freakishly good. Begun by the wonderful Buying New Soul, the collection includes some B-sides and other previously unreleased gems.
I love these kinds of compilations because often the band experiments wonderfully on those kinds of items. Recordings is no different. This is one of my most played PT albums.
Next up is In Absentia - still my favourite Porcupine Tree album. Gavin Harrison replaces Chris Maitland on drums and is a great fit for these muscular songs and Prog Metal moves that the band now bring to the party on In Absentia.
The quiet/ loud dynamic works brilliantly on the opener Blackest Eyes and onward; the harmonies are terrific and the singing by Steven Wilson has never been better than on this album. Elsewhere there are great pop songs (The Sound of Muzak); prog metal blasts of riff rock (Wedding Nails) and Radiohead style rock experimentation.
The variety and brilliant execution makes it a terrific package - AllMusic summed the album up well: 'Sonically gorgeous and deceivingly complex, In Absentia has the most immediate appeal of anything Wilson has released under this moniker up to this point'.
Commercially, it did the business as well - In Absentia sold three times as many copies as any of their earlier albums.
How to follow that peak? Deadwing continued the successful sound of In Absentia, and was even more commercially successful!
The album has its origins in a screenplay for a ghost story written by Steven Wilson and Mike Bennion. Many of the songs were originally intended for the film soundtrack, but when the project failed to get off the ground, they were instead recorded for the next Porcupine Tree album.
The songs stand alone, and it all adds up to another embarrassment of riches album - plenty of experimentation, plenty of riffs and plenty of catchy choruses - all recognisably Porcupine Tree. Not quite as inspired as In Absentia, but still - a consistently excellent album.
Fear of a Blank Planet, their ninth studio effort, is a mellower album in comparison to In Absentia and Deadwing. Steven Wilson's singing is quieter and more restrained throughout which suits the thoughtful and worthy subject matter - the fear of losing the current generation of youth to various common threats to their mental and social wellbeing, including broken homes, excessive screen time, and narcotic overuse (prescribed and otherwise) to the point of mental and spiritual blankness.
As with most concept albums, I tend to lose the plot along the way and just enjoy the music. Commercially it was their highest selling album to this point. It was also a hit with the critics.
Nil Recurring is a lengthy E.P. - almost half an hour; some albums are that long. It's comprised of four songs recorded during the Fear of a Blank Planet sessions. The title track features Robert Fripp on guitar. It's a standout track in their catalogue.
The Anesthetize package is of high quality, as per usual. Attention to detail in the presentation of PT and SW albums is exhaustive.
This time, the live in the Netherlands document comes as two CDs and a DVD. The band were touring Fear of a Blank Planet so material from that album and Nil Recurring is featured heavily.
The multi-layered PT sound from the studio means they need some help in a live setting. During this concert guitarist/ vocalist John Wesley helps flesh out the sound and does a great job. It's fun watching him and the rest of PT do their thing. Steven Wilson is the most animated, and so my eye naturally goes to him in centre-stage.
The Incident is their next studio album and again it topped the other albums commercially (this one is the peak of their popularity so far).
The concept this time centres around trying to humanise news media reports of traumatic events such as a car crash. This means that the title song goes for 55 minutes and exists in 14 parts. Disc 2 has four songs not attached to the concept that add another 20 minutes. So, in old money this would have been called a double album.
Whatever, it rocks and rolls and unfolds a fascinating series of songs joined together into a suite that rewards repeat listens. It would be the last studio album for quite a while, and Colin Edwin's final studio album as the bassist.
Octane Twisted is a live album documenting the tour supporting The Incident. The whole album is performed during the concert in Chicago, 2010. with the remainder being songs from the band's catalogue. Its highlights include an extended Hatesong, a 15-minute medley of Russia on Ice/"The Pills I'm Taking and Arriving Somewhere But Not Here. The package again includes a DVD of the performance.
That would be it for Porcupine Tree until a surprise resurfacing in 2022 with Closure/ Continuation (SW hedging his bets). The record emerged from earlier writing sessions between Wilson and Gavin Harrison begun shortly after The Incident. Eventually they evolved into the final forms on Closure/ Continuation with assistance from Richard Barbieri.
Where do they all belong? Steven Wilson's solo albums are yet to come.